Stamping Document

Mortgage "Stripped Off" in Chapter 13 Bankruptcy Due to Bank's Error

Under a Chapter 13 bankruptcy, a debtor reorganizes his or her debt and has a set period of time to make payments, generally three to five years. This reorganization may provide relief to a debtor, and possibly avoid a home foreclosure in certain circumstances. In fact, if a home has more than one mortgage, and the value of the home is less than the value of the first mortgage, it may even be possible to "strip off" a second mortgage entirely.

The recent United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit case of In re Rodriguez not only discussed the concept of "stripping" a second mortgage, but also demonstrated how complete and absolute a confirmed plan of repayment can be, protecting the debtor even in unusual circumstances.

A second mortgage . . . and a hearing missed

The debtors filed for a Chapter 13 bankruptcy, which through the proceedings resulted in the creation of a Chapter 13 plan. As part of this plan, the debtors wished to "strip off" the second mortgage on their home.

The bank holding the second mortgage objected to the plan because the debtors' residence was worth more than the value of the first mortgage. As part of the objection, the bank requested a hearing on the matter.

However, the bank failed to appear at the hearing, and, in addition, claimed that a "computer glitch" had kept the bankruptcy trustee-the individual tasked with administering the bankruptcy-from knowing about the bank's objection. Thus, at the confirmation hearing, the debtor's plan was confirmed and the second bank's mortgage was stripped off.

The bank filed a motion seeking relief from the confirmed plan, on the basis of excusable neglect.

The debt discharge was absolute

The Third Circuit Court of Appeals held that the bank's attempt to revisit the proceedings would disturb the confirmation order to an impermissible extent under the federal bankruptcy laws.

The purpose of bankruptcy law and the reorganization of a debtors obligations could not be accomplished if the discharge of debtors through bankruptcy was not complete and absolute. In such a case, the very policy of the law would be defeated.

The bank should have raised its challenge at the confirmation hearing, and having not raised its objection until after the repayment plan was confirmed, the "stripping off" of the second mortgage would stand.

Avoiding foreclosure

While the specific circumstances of this case may have been unusual, it is very common for a homeowner to find relief through a Chapter 13 bankruptcy. Typically, lien stripping of a mortgage occurs when the underlying home's value does not cover the claim of the first mortgage. But even if "stripping" is not an option, a foreclosure might still be stopped and a repayment plan put in place. If you are considering a bankruptcy, consult with an experienced bankruptcy attorney who can review your individual situation and guide you through the entire process.

Get To Know David & Robert

  • David  Alan Ast Photo
    David Alan Ast
    Firm Partner David Alan Ast has more than 25 years of experience helping people throughout northern New Jersey get a fresh start and move forward with their financial lives. He is committed to protecting the rights of his clients seeking debt relief.
  • Robert L. Schmidt Photo
    Robert L. Schmidt
    Firm Partner Robert L. Schmidt earned his Bachelor of Arts in Business Administration and Finance from Stockton State College in 1990. Three years later, he earned his Master’s degree from Rutgers University School of Business in Camden with a major in finance. Robert then acquired his J.D. from James E. Beasley School of Law at Temple University in 1997.
/

Real Stories Inspired From Real Situations

Reviews
  • “They were always understanding of our concerns and patient with our questions. Thank you all!”

    - Ann R.
  • “One that is there to help instead of someone who will treat you like another number. 5 stars isn't enough.”

    - M.H., Chapter 7 Client
  • “'m am very grateful to have hired this firm. It was smooth and now I can breathe again. Thank you, everyone, at Ast & Schmidt.”

    - Rich L.

What Sets Us Apart

How We Can Help You 
Move Forward
  • Personalized Services Tailored for You
  • Over 30 Years of Bankruptcy Experience
  • Free Initial Consultations
  • Available After Hours by Appointment
  • Direct Advice from Our Attorneys
  • Realistic Expectations Provided

Begin Your Fresh Start

Our team has over 30 years helping clients.  Let us help you.
  • Please enter your first name.
  • Please enter your last name.
  • Please enter your phone number.
    This isn't a valid phone number.
  • Please enter your email address.
    This isn't a valid email address.
  • Please make a selection.
  • Please enter a message.